Home › views
views

Rings of Power Keeps Turning Middle-earth Into a Dating Show

The trailer for *The Rings of Power* Season 3 was hit with a copyright claim and had to be removed. Honestly, that may be the first merciful decision anyone involved with this production has made.

Rings of Power Keeps Turning Middle-earth Into a Dating Show

There is a special kind of failure involved in taking The Lord of the Rings and turning it into a love triangle.

This is Tolkien’s world. It is supposed to be a story about power, sacrifice, courage, corruption, friendship, and the long shadow of evil. There are wars to fight, kingdoms to save, and ancient forces trying to destroy the world.

So naturally, The Rings of Power appears to be leaning into romantic drama between Galadriel, Sauron, and her husband, Celeborn.

Somehow, Middle-earth has become a supernatural young-adult drama.

Welcome to Middle-earth High

The trailer was reportedly designed to tease a choice for Galadriel: her husband or Sauron. The show’s stars and writers have tried to avoid calling it a love triangle, but the marketing is clearly aimed at the shipping crowd.

That is what makes this so ridiculous. You can call it a “complicated relationship,” a “dynamic,” or whatever other corporate phrase is trending this week. If the story is asking viewers to wonder whether Galadriel might choose her husband or the Dark Lord, then congratulations. You have created a love triangle.

And yes, we understand that the show wants to make Sauron charismatic. That part is obvious. The problem is that the series keeps confusing romantic tension with dramatic substance.

There is a difference between portraying temptation and asking the audience to cheer for a pairing that should make any Tolkien fan want to walk into the sea.

The trailer’s biggest problem is not simply that it looks bad. It is that it reveals what the show thinks The Lord of the Rings is for. The answer seems to be: familiar names, fan-service arguments, and enough relationship drama to keep social media occupied between episodes.

The trailer disappeared, and nobody is mourning

The trailer featured in the original video received a copyright claim and had to be removed. We hate to say it, but this might be the most effective act of audience protection associated with The Rings of Power so far.

At least the footage is gone.

That does not erase what it showed us, though. The marketing has already made the direction clear. Instead of selling viewers on the grandeur of Middle-earth, the show is selling them on who Galadriel might kiss, which character has the stronger connection with her, and whether Sauron can somehow become the dark horse romantic option.

This is the same old Hollywood habit of treating an existing audience as raw material.

The people who already love Tolkien are assumed to be locked in. The people who do not care about Tolkien are treated as the real growth opportunity. So the studio adds whatever it thinks will attract a modern streaming audience: relationship drama, fan-fiction logic, and a story structure that could be pasted onto almost any fantasy property.

The result is neither a faithful adaptation nor an exciting original series. It is a very expensive imitation of things that were popular five years ago.

The missing ingredient is cool

The biggest problem with modern franchise entertainment is not that every story needs to be dark or violent. It is that so many of these properties have lost their sense of cool.

Star Wars was cool. Star Trek was cool. The original Lord of the Rings films were cool. They had characters who looked like they belonged in legends. They had danger, mystery, scale, and moments that made you want to replay the scene immediately.

What does The Rings of Power give us instead?

A suspiciously modern emotional vocabulary. Characters debating their feelings while ancient evil gathers around them. Endless speeches about destiny. A story that keeps insisting its characters are important instead of giving us scenes that prove it.

Even the most basic fantasy pleasures feel strangely absent. Where are the scenes that make us want to see someone draw a sword? Where are the monsters that feel genuinely frightening? Where is the sense that these people are moving through a world larger and older than themselves?

The Peter Jackson films understood that Tolkien’s world could support spectacle. The battles were not the whole point, but they gave the stories muscle. They made Middle-earth feel dangerous. When Elrond, Galadriel, and Saruman confronted the Nazgûl at Dol Guldur, the scene was not a literal recreation of Tolkien’s text. It was still memorable because it understood the assignment.

The Rings of Power keeps giving us conversations about what the assignment means.

The audience was never the problem

Hollywood has spent years trying to invent a “modern audience” that supposedly wants to be lectured, corrected, and handed a replacement for the stories it already enjoys.

That audience does not really exist in the way executives imagine it does. People are perfectly capable of enjoying old stories. They watch old Star Trek. They rewatch The Lord of the Rings. They read books written decades or centuries ago. They do not need a committee to retrofit every property with the latest cultural fashion.

The audience is not opposed to new characters or different interpretations. We are opposed to being told that the things we loved were defective and that the replacement deserves our loyalty because it has the right talking points.

That is why the phrase “modern audience” has become such a punchline. It often means that the people who built the audience are being pushed aside for people who do not actually want the original thing.

If you want to make a romance-heavy fantasy series, make one. If you want to make a political allegory, make one. If you want to write a show about doomed young lovers, there are thousands of settings available.

But when you take Tolkien’s mythology, remove the qualities that made it powerful, and replace them with shipping discourse, do not be surprised when fans recognize the theft.

Final take

The problem with The Rings of Power is not that it is too different from the books in one isolated detail. The problem is that it keeps changing the center of gravity.

Tolkien’s world is about moral choices under pressure. This show keeps drifting toward romantic intrigue, franchise branding, and whatever online fandom niche the marketing department thinks can be activated.

That is not adaptation. That is IP management with costumes.

We will probably keep watching the train wreck because somebody has to document what happened to Middle-earth. But if Season 3 really wants to turn Galadriel and Sauron into the fantasy version of a forbidden romance, it should at least be honest about what it is making.

This is not The Lord of the Rings.

It is a very expensive fan-fiction relationship chart with elves.

Subscribe to Game Pilled: https://www.youtube.com/@GamePilledBlog
Join the Based New Wave!